Book Review - Southern Exposure

Speaking in Tongues

Southern Exposure: Modern Japanese Literature From Okinawa
Edited by Michael Molasky and Steve Rabson
University of Hawaii Press
362 pages

"Where are you from," she asked.
I thought about where I was from and lit a cigarette.
The place colored by associations with tattoos, the jabisen,
And ways as strange as ornamental designs.
"Very far away," I answered.
-- Yamanokuchi Baku


Southern Exposure has grand designs: it is at once an anthology of Okinawan literature, a cultural survey of the region, a historical primer, a chronicle of otherness. Those familiar with the area will have an inkling of what this means: lyrical seaside settings, unique indigenous traditions sandwiched between the condescension of mainland Japan and the ever-present U.S. military, a history haunted by invasion in World War II and contemporary marginalization. Even the barbed wire-&-beach cover suggests this isn't going to be disposable summertime reading.

To their credit, Michael Molasky and Steve Rabson understand the enormity of this enterprise: their informative introduction includes a rueful four pages on the vagaries of translating Okinawan regional dialects into English. Fortunately for them (and us), the writers they feature are a dazzling bunch, easily transcending the stuffiness which can plague collections such as these.

The anthology is comprised of fiction (eleven stories and a novella) and a smattering of poetry from the past eighty years. All of them address similar concerns: displaced lives and roots, the disconnect between traditional obligations and current necessities, an uneasy present built upon the past's ruins (or as in Shima Tsuyoshi's amusing yet affecting story "Bones" (1973), literally built atop the bones of war victims). What saves it all from mere didacticism is the writers' feel for the rhythms and details of daily life. In their hands, normalcy becomes captivating, whether it be a mandatory visit to the relatives, scrapping together enough dough for a motorcycle, maintaining that fishing routine, calculating the proper appeasement for ancestors, flirting with the boyish G.I., or stealing a goat in order to earn a comely bar owner's kudos. The characters who populate these narratives are a colorful bunch: one-armed farmers, ornery elders, lecherous shysters, wrinkled-up prostitutes, murderous adulterers, and corrupt policemen. Much as Okinawa has struggled to rise above oppression and isolation, we witness the collision of the desperate and mundane in these narratives.

Some of the pieces have obviously been chosen for their political utility: Kushi Fusako's "Memoirs of a Declining Ryukyuan Woman" (1932), which is referred to at least a dozen times in the introduction, is a polished but slight anecdote about "passing" as a mainland Japanese. More interesting is Kushi's written defense of her work in the face of snotty Japanese critics, which is included here. Passing and its emotional toll are also dealt with in "Officer Ukuma" (1922) and "Mr. Saito of Heaven Building" (1938), the predicaments of both stories' titular protagonists - paranoid men in acknowledged positions of power -reminiscent of the best Harlem Renaissance literature.

Other stories are character studies filtered through the lens of specific regional experience: Yoshida Sueko's "Love Suicide at Kamaara" (1984) is a languorous but touching tale about the love of a local hooker well past her prime for a G.I. deserter who is clueless about the whole double-suicide thing. Likewise, Kishaba Jun's "Dark Flowers" (1955), Nakahara Shin's "The Silver Motorcycle" (1977), and Shimokawa Hiroshi's "Love Letter From L.A." (1978) center on Okinawan women, the U.S. military men they love and lose, and the disapproving eyes of friends and neighbors. The latter, in its progression from mild jealousy to outright psychological cruelty, is particularly devastating.

The longer pieces in the collection stretch their artistic muscles. Oshiro Tatsuhiro's "Turtleback Tombs" (1966) presents the step-by-step disintegration of a local family during the American bombings of Okinawa - in its scorched-earth grit and the family's stubborn adherence to ancient traditions, it is an elegy to an overwhelmed way of life. Yamanoha Nobuko's "Will 'o the Wisp" (1985) is another tour-de-force, merging evocative underwater settings with a hallucinatory narrative told from the point of view of a drowned woman and her unborn child. And Medoruma Shun's "Droplets," which won the prestigious Akutagawa Prize in 1997, melds Dostoyevskian psychology with fabulist touches, as a man tormented by the ghosts of dead soldiers must endure a melon-sized growth on his leg which drips with elixirs and poisons.

The concluding novella, Matayoshi Eiki's "Fortunes by the Sea" (1998), ends the collection on a properly bemused note. In its dry prose, its witty frankness when it comes to sex and other sordid matters, and its lovable anti-hero - an emasculated househusband who can't even take a boat out to sea without vomiting - the story is redolent of hip contemporary literature. But our man doesn't find his manhood: he botches his chance for adultery, his robbery scheme goes awry, and he still isn't much of a fisherman by story's end. Yet he emerges with his sense of wonder intact. Much like the rest of Southern Exposure and the region this anthology celebrates, the piece is sad but never self-pitying, funny but substantial, artful but not arty, and above all, a tribute to survival. .